何兆洋等：管道内气液两相流流激力研究进展 135· induced forces on bends in small scale tubes /Proceedings of the [20]Pettigrew M J,Zhang C,Mureithi N W,et al.Detailed flow and ASME 2009 Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference.Volume 4: force measurements in a rotated triangular tube bundle subjected to Fluid-Structure Interaction.Prague,2009:369 two-phase cross-flow.J Fluids Struct,2005,20(4):567 [5]Riverin JL,de Langre E,Pettigrew M J.Fluctuating forces caused [21]Miwa S,Mori M,Hibiki T.Two-phase flow induced vibration in by intemal two-phase flow on bends and tees.J Sound Vib,2006. piping systems.Prog Nucl Energy,2015,78:270 298(4-5:1088 [22]Yih T S,Griffith P.Unsteady Momentum Fhrxes in Two-phase [6] Riverin JL,Pettigrew MJ.Fluctuating forces in U-tubes subjected Flow and The Vibration of Nuclear Reactor Components to internal two-phase flow /l Proceedings of the ASME 2005 [Dissertation].Massachusetts:Massachusetts Institute of Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference.Volume 4:Fluid Technology,1968 Structure Interaction.Denver,2005:547 [23]Cargnelutti M F,Belfroid S P C,Schiferli W,et al.Multiphase [7]Parsi M,Nair A,Kara M,et al.Condition based assessment of fluid structure interaction in bends and T-joints /Proceedingsof subsea rigid jumpers using advanced analytical model 0h the ASME 2010 Pressure Vessels and Piping Division/K-PVP North American Conference on Multiphase Technology.Banff, Conference.ASME 2010 Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference: 2016:BHR-2016-245 Volume 4.Bellevue,2010:75 [8]Smeulers J P M.Diez N G.Slot H.Flow induced vibration in [24]Giraudeau M.Mureithi N W,Pettigrew M J.Two-phase flow- subsea production systems /SPE Russian Oil and Gas induced forces on piping in vertical upward flow:excitation Exploration and Production Technical Conference and Exhibition. mechanisms and correlation models.J Pressure Vessel Technol, Moscow,2012:SPE-160727-MS 2013,135(3):030907 [9]Wang L,Yang Y R,Li Y X,et al.Resonance analyses of a [25]Liu Y,Miwa S,Hibiki T,et al.Experimental study of internal two- pipeline-riser system conveying gas-liquid two-phase flow with phase flow induced fluctuating force on a 90 elbow.Chem Eng flow-patter evolution.Int/Press Vessels Pip,2018,161:22 Sci,2012,76:173 [10]Liu HG,Kong J Y,LiG F,et al.Inquiry into vibration analysis [26]Miwa S,Liu Y,Hibiki T,et al.Two-phase flow induced force and control of fluid filled pipe system.J Hubei Univ Technol, fluctuations on pipe bend Proceedings of the 2014 22nd 2005,20(3):78 International Conference on Nuclear Engineering.Volume 2B: (刘怀广，孔建益，李公法，等.充液管道系统振动分析与控制的 Thermal Hydraulics.Prague,Czech Republic,2014: 探讨.湖北工业大学学报，2005,20(3)：78) V02BT09A007 [11]Jia D.Slug flow induced vibration in a pipeline span,a jumper and [27]Miwa S,Hibiki T,Mori M.Analysis of flow-induced vibration due a riser section /l Offshore Technology Conference.Houston,2012: to stratified wavy two-phase flow.J Fluids Eng,2016,138(9): 0TC-22935-MS 091302 [12]Tay BL.Thorpe R B.Statistical analysis of the hydrodynamic [28]de Henau V,Raithby G D.A study of terrain-induced slugging in forces acting on pipe bends in gas-liquid slug flow and their two-phase flow pipelines.InJMultiphase Flow,1995.21(3):365 relation to fatigue.Chem Eng Res Des,2015,104:457 [29]Al-Safran E.Investigation and prediction of slug frequency in [13]Pettigrew M J,Taylor C E,Fisher N J,et al.Flow-induced gas/liquid horizontal pipe flow.JPerrol Sci Eng,009,69(1-2): vibration:recent findings and open questions.Nucl Eng Des,1998. 143 185(2-3):249 [30]Peddu A,Chakraborty S,Das P K.Visualization and flow regime [14]Swindell R.Hidden integrity threat looms in subsea pipework identification of downward air-water flow through a 12 mm vibrations.Offshore,2011,71(9):78 diameter vertical tube using image analysis.Int J Multiphase Flow, [15]de Langre E,Villard B.An upper bound on random buffeting 2018.100:1 forces caused by two-phase flows across tubes.J Fluids Struct, [31]Barnea D,Shoham O,Taitel Y.Flow pattem characterization in 1998,12(8):1005 two phase flow by electrical conductance probe.Int J Multiphase [16]Sakaguchi T.Ozawa M,Hamaguchi H,et al.Analysis of the F1ow,1980,6(5):387 impact force by a transient liquid slug flowing out of a horizontal [32]Taitel Y,Lee N,Dukler A E.Transient gas-liquid flow in pipe.Nucl Eng Des,1987,99:63 horizontal pipes:Modeling the flow pattern transitions.A/ChEJ, [17]Mulcahy T M,Lawrence W,Wambsganss M W.Dynamic surface 1978.24(5):920 pressure instrumentation for rods in parallel flow.Exp Mech,1982 [33]Hewitt G F.Measurement of Two-Phase Flow Parameters. 22(1):31 London and New York:Academic Press,1978 [18]Chu I C,Chung H J,Lee S.Flow-induced vibration of nuclear [34]Chen Z Y,He L M.Experimental study on measuring steam generator U-tubes in two-phase flow.Nuc/Eng Des,2011. characteristics of slug flow in horizontal pipe.JUniv Petrol China 241(5):1508 Nat Sci,2003,27(1):67 [19]Sasakawa T,Serizawa A,Kawara Z.Fluid-elastic vibration in two- (陈振瑜，何利民.水平管段塞流特征参数测量方法的试验研究 phase cross flow.Exp Therm Fluid Sci,2005,29(3):403 石油大学学报：自然科学版，2003,27(1)：67)induced forces on bends in small scale tubes // Proceedings of the ASME 2009 Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference. Volume 4: Fluid-Structure Interaction. Prague, 2009: 369 Riverin J L, de Langre E, Pettigrew M J. Fluctuating forces caused by internal two-phase flow on bends and tees. J Sound Vib, 2006, 298（4-5）: 1088 [5] Riverin J L, Pettigrew M J. Fluctuating forces in U-tubes subjected to  internal  two-phase  flow  // Proceedings of the ASME 2005 Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference. Volume 4: Fluid Structure Interaction. Denver, 2005: 547 [6] Parsi  M,  Nair  A,  Kara  M,  et  al.  Condition  based  assessment  of subsea  rigid  jumpers  using  advanced  analytical  model  //  10th North American Conference on Multiphase Technology.  Banff, 2016: BHR-2016-245 [7] Smeulers  J  P  M,  Diez  N  G,  Slot  H.  Flow  induced  vibration  in subsea  production  systems  // SPE Russian Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Technical Conference and Exhibition. Moscow, 2012: SPE-160727-MS [8] Wang  L,  Yang  Y  R,  Li  Y  X,  et  al.  Resonance  analyses  of  a pipeline-riser  system  conveying  gas-liquid  two-phase  flow  with flow-pattern evolution. Int J Press Vessels Pip, 2018, 161: 22 [9] Liu H G, Kong J Y, Li G F, et al. Inquiry into vibration analysis and  control  of  fluid  filled  pipe  system. J Hubei Univ Technol, 2005, 20（3）: 78 （刘怀广, 孔建益, 李公法, 等. 充液管道系统振动分析与控制的 探讨. 湖北工业大学学报, 2005, 20（3）：78） [10] Jia D. Slug flow induced vibration in a pipeline span, a jumper and a riser section // Offshore Technology Conference. Houston, 2012: OTC-22935-MS [11] Tay  B  L,  Thorpe  R  B.  Statistical  analysis  of  the  hydrodynamic forces  acting  on  pipe  bends  in  gas –liquid  slug  flow  and  their relation to fatigue. Chem Eng Res Des, 2015, 104: 457 [12] Pettigrew  M  J,  Taylor  C  E,  Fisher  N  J,  et  al.  Flow-induced vibration: recent findings and open questions. Nucl Eng Des, 1998, 185（2-3）: 249 [13] Swindell  R.  Hidden  integrity  threat  looms  in  subsea  pipework vibrations. Offshore, 2011, 71（9）: 78 [14] de  Langre  E,  Villard  B.  An  upper  bound  on  random  buffeting forces  caused  by  two-phase  flows  across  tubes. J Fluids Struct, 1998, 12（8）: 1005 [15] Sakaguchi  T,  Ozawa  M,  Hamaguchi  H,  et  al.  Analysis  of  the impact force by a transient liquid slug flowing out of a horizontal pipe. Nucl Eng Des, 1987, 99: 63 [16] Mulcahy T M, Lawrence W, Wambsganss M W. Dynamic surface￾pressure instrumentation for rods in parallel flow. Exp Mech, 1982, 22（1）: 31 [17] Chu  I  C,  Chung  H  J,  Lee  S.  Flow-induced  vibration  of  nuclear steam generator U-tubes in two-phase flow. Nucl Eng Des, 2011, 241（5）: 1508 [18] Sasakawa T, Serizawa A, Kawara Z. Fluid-elastic vibration in two￾phase cross flow. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 2005, 29（3）: 403 [19] Pettigrew M J, Zhang C, Mureithi N W, et al. Detailed flow and force measurements in a rotated triangular tube bundle subjected to two-phase cross-flow. J Fluids Struct, 2005, 20（4）: 567 [20] Miwa S, Mori M, Hibiki T. Two-phase flow induced vibration in piping systems. Prog Nucl Energy, 2015, 78: 270 [21] Yih  T  S,  Griffith  P. Unsteady Momentum Fluxes in Two-phase Flow and The Vibration of Nuclear Reactor Components [Dissertation].  Massachusetts:  Massachusetts  Institute  of Technology, 1968 [22] Cargnelutti  M  F,  Belfroid  S  P  C,  Schiferli  W,  et  al.  Multiphase fluid structure interaction in bends and T-joints // Proceedings of the ASME 2010 Pressure Vessels and Piping Division/K-PVP Conference. ASME 2010 Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference: Volume 4. Bellevue, 2010: 75 [23] Giraudeau  M,  Mureithi  N  W,  Pettigrew  M  J.  Two-phase  flow￾induced  forces  on  piping  in  vertical  upward  flow:  excitation mechanisms  and  correlation  models. J Pressure Vessel Technol, 2013, 135（3）: 030907 [24] Liu Y, Miwa S, Hibiki T, et al. Experimental study of internal two￾phase  flow  induced  fluctuating  force  on  a  90°  elbow. Chem Eng Sci, 2012, 76: 173 [25] Miwa  S,  Liu  Y,  Hibiki  T,  et  al.  Two-phase  flow  induced  force fluctuations  on  pipe  bend  // Proceedings of the 2014  22nd International Conference on Nuclear Engineering. Volume 2B: Thermal Hydraulics.  Prague,  Czech  Republic,  2014: V02BT09A007 [26] Miwa S, Hibiki T, Mori M. Analysis of flow-induced vibration due to  stratified  wavy  two-phase  flow. J Fluids Eng,  2016,  138（9）: 091302 [27] de Henau V, Raithby G D. A study of terrain-induced slugging in two-phase flow pipelines. Int J Multiphase Flow, 1995, 21（3）: 365 [28] Al-Safran  E.  Investigation  and  prediction  of  slug  frequency  in gas/liquid horizontal pipe flow. J Petrol Sci Eng, 2009, 69（1-2）: 143 [29] Peddu A, Chakraborty S, Das P K. Visualization and flow regime identification  of  downward  air –water  flow  through  a  12  mm diameter vertical tube using image analysis. Int J Multiphase Flow, 2018, 100: 1 [30] Barnea  D,  Shoham  O,  Taitel  Y.  Flow  pattern  characterization  in two phase flow by electrical conductance probe. Int J Multiphase Flow, 1980, 6（5）: 387 [31] Taitel  Y,  Lee  N,  Dukler  A  E.  Transient  gas-liquid  flow  in horizontal pipes: Modeling the flow pattern transitions. AIChE J, 1978, 24（5）: 920 [32] Hewitt  G  F. Measurement of Two-Phase Flow Parameters. London and New York: Academic Press, 1978 [33] Chen  Z  Y,  He  L  M.  Experimental  study  on  measuring characteristics of slug flow in horizontal pipe. J Univ Petrol China Nat Sci, 2003, 27（1）: 67 （陈振瑜, 何利民. 水平管段塞流特征参数测量方法的试验研究. 石油大学学报: 自然科学版, 2003, 27（1）：67） [34] 何兆洋等： 管道内气液两相流流激力研究进展 · 135 ·