nature publishing grour How to make an appeal? Write(not phone) to us and explain why you believe we(referees and editors)have overlooked or misunderstood something Revised manuscripts normally go back to the same referees; need a strong case to replace a referee as they normally come back with new set of points The paper must not be submitted for publication elsewhere during this time It is likely that some time will elapse before we can respond g nature asia-pacihic h A Established 1987 as Nature Japan K.K.Rachel PC Won • Write (not phone) to us and explain why you believe we (referees and editors) have overlooked or misunderstood something • Revised manuscripts normally go back to the same referees; need a strong case to replace a referee as they normally come back with new set of points • The paper must not be submitted for publication elsewhere during this time • It is likely that some time will elapse before we can respond www.nature.com/naturephotonics How to make an appeal?