362 工程科学学报，第43卷，第3期 人机动态协同控制的车道保持辅助系统，从车道 [9]Guo L,Li L H.Vehicle Driving Safery Assistance Technology. 偏离决策模型到驾驶权动态分配方式，再到该系 Beijing:Peking University Press,2014 统的性能评估指标，按照时间顺序展开论述.在车 (郭烈，李琳辉.汽车安全辅助驾驶技术.北京：北京大学出版社， 2014) 道偏离决策模型部分，通过列举不同的决策模型， [10]ISO 17361 -2017.Intelligent Transportation Systems -Lane 讨论了决策模型的设计要求，分析目前决策模型 Departure Warning Systems-Performance Requirements and Test 的优缺点，总结了决策模型的几种发展方向.在驾 Procedures.London:British Standards Institution,2017 驶权动态分配方式部分，将驾驶员与控制器的驾 [11]Lin C F.Ulsoy A G.Time to lane crossing calculation and 驶权动态分配方式分为3类，介绍了控制模型中 characterization of its associated uncertainty.Intell Transp Syst, 用到的算法，对比了驾驶权动态分配方式之间的 1996,3(2):85 优缺点，整理了该部分的发展方向.在性能评估部 [12]Chang TH,Hsu C S.Wang C.et al.Onboard measurement and waming module for irregular vehicle behavior.IEEE Trans Intel 分，重点列举了性能评估参数，总结了性能评估的 Ta1pys,2008,9(3):501 待改进之处.对于基于人机动态协同控制的车道 [13]Falcone P,Ali M,Sjoberg J.Predictive threat assessment via 保持辅助系统，未来的研究将更多地考虑驾驶员 reachability analysis and set invariance theory.IEEE Trans Intell 因素，实时警报及进行主动控制干预，利用数字孪 Transp3H,2011,12(4):1352 生等先进技术建立完善的测试及评估体系 [14]Li X P,Seignez E,Loonis P,et al.Vision-based estimation of driving inattention fused via Dempster-Shafer theory /IEEE 参考文献 International Conference on Cyber Technology in Automation. Control,Intelligent Systems.Bangkok,2012:393 [1]Inagaki T.Smart collaboration between humans and machines [15]Nalla P,Goud G C L A,Padmaja V.Accident avoiding system based on mutual understanding.Ann Rev Control,2008,32(2): using lane detection.Int J Rev Electron Commun Eng,2013,1(1): 253 1 [2]Nobe S A,Wang F Y.An overview of recent developments in [16]Batavia P H.Driver-Adaptive Lane Departure Warning Systems. automated lateral and longitudinal vehicle controls /2001 IEEE Pittsburgh:Carnegie Mellon University,1999 International Conference on Systems.Man and Cybernetics.e- [17]Jung C R.Kelber C R.A lane departure warning system using Systems and e-Man for Cybernetics in Cyberspace (Cat.No. lateral offset with uncalibrated camera /Intelligent Transportation 01CH37236).Tucson,2001:3447 Systems.Vienna,2005:102 [3]Song L H,Guo H Y,Wang F,et al.Model predictive control [18]Liu X H.Development of A Vision-Based Object Detection and oriented shared steering control for intelligent vehicles /29th Recognition System for Intelligent Vehicle [Dissertation] Chinese Control and Decision Conference.Chongqing,2017:7568 Wisconsin:University of Wisconsin-Madison,2000 [4]Narote S P,Bhujbal P N,Narote A S,et al.A review of recent [19]Wu D H,Ye X J,Gu W K.An uncertain knowledge based real advances in lane detection and departure warning system.Pattern time road scene understanding algorithm.J Image Graph,2002, Recognit,,2018,73:216 7(1):69 [5]Li K Q.Review of status and future prospects of automotive (吴东晖，叶秀清，顾伟康.基于不确定性知识的实时道路场景 intelligent safety electronics.Chin J Automor Eng,2011,1(1):4 理解.中国图象图形学报，2002,7(1)：69) (李克强.汽车智能安全电子技术发展现状与展望.汽车工程学 [20]Gonzalez-Mendoza M,Jammes B,Hernandez-Gress N,et al.A 报，20111(1)：4) comparison of road departure waming systems on real driving [6]Zhao X J,Chen H Y.A study on lateral control method for the conditions /7th International IEEE Conference on Intelligent path tracking of intelligent vehicles.Automot Eng,2011,33(5): Transportation Systems.Washington,2004:349 382 [21]Zhou Y,Xu R,Hu X F,et al.A lane departure warning system (赵熙俊，陈慧岩.智能车辆路径跟踪横向控制方法的研究.汽 based on virtual lane boundary.J Inf Sci Eng,2008,24(1):293 车工程，2011,33(5)：382) [22]Godthelp H,Milgram P,Blaauw G J.The development of a time- [7]Flemisch F,Kelsch J,Loper C,et al.Cooperative control and related measure to describe driving strategy.Human Factors, active interfaces for vehicle assitsance and automation /FIS/TA 1984.26(3):257 World Automotive Congress.Munchen,2008 [23]Enkelmann W.Video-based driver assistance from basic [8]Hu Y F,Qu T,Liu J,et al.Human-machine cooperative control of functions to applications.IntJComput Vision,2001,45(3):201 intelligent vehicle:recent developments and future perspectives [24]Xu L H,Luo Q,Zhang L Y,et al.Research on variable virtual lane Acta Autom Sin,2019,45(7):1261 boundary for lane departure warning systems.Adv Transp Studies, (胡云峰，曲婷，刘俊，等.智能汽车人机协同控制的研究现状与 2014,32:37 展望.自动化学报，2019,45(7)：1261) [25]Zhang WW,Song X L,Zhang G X.Real-Time lane departure人机动态协同控制的车道保持辅助系统，从车道 偏离决策模型到驾驶权动态分配方式，再到该系 统的性能评估指标，按照时间顺序展开论述. 在车 道偏离决策模型部分，通过列举不同的决策模型， 讨论了决策模型的设计要求，分析目前决策模型 的优缺点，总结了决策模型的几种发展方向. 在驾 驶权动态分配方式部分，将驾驶员与控制器的驾 驶权动态分配方式分为 3 类，介绍了控制模型中 用到的算法，对比了驾驶权动态分配方式之间的 优缺点，整理了该部分的发展方向. 在性能评估部 分，重点列举了性能评估参数，总结了性能评估的 待改进之处. 对于基于人机动态协同控制的车道 保持辅助系统，未来的研究将更多地考虑驾驶员 因素，实时警报及进行主动控制干预，利用数字孪 生等先进技术建立完善的测试及评估体系. 参    考    文    献 Inagaki  T.  Smart  collaboration  between  humans  and  machines based  on  mutual  understanding. Ann Rev Control,  2008,  32（2）: 253 [1] Nobe  S  A,  Wang  F  Y.  An  overview  of  recent  developments  in automated  lateral  and  longitudinal  vehicle  controls  //  2001 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics. e￾Systems and e-Man for Cybernetics in Cyberspace (Cat. No. 01CH37236). Tucson, 2001: 3447 [2] Song  L  H,  Guo  H  Y,  Wang  F,  et  al.  Model  predictive  control oriented  shared  steering  control  for  intelligent  vehicles  //  29th Chinese Control and Decision Conference. Chongqing, 2017: 7568 [3] Narote  S  P,  Bhujbal  P  N,  Narote  A  S,  et  al.  A  review  of  recent advances in lane detection and departure warning system. Pattern Recognit, 2018, 73: 216 [4] Li  K  Q.  Review  of  status  and  future  prospects  of  automotive intelligent safety electronics. Chin J Automot Eng, 2011, 1（1）: 4 （李克强. 汽车智能安全电子技术发展现状与展望. 汽车工程学 报, 2011, 1（1）：4） [5] Zhao  X  J,  Chen  H  Y.  A  study  on  lateral  control  method  for  the path  tracking  of  intelligent  vehicles. Automot Eng,  2011,  33（5）: 382 （赵熙俊, 陈慧岩. 智能车辆路径跟踪横向控制方法的研究. 汽 车工程, 2011, 33（5）：382） [6] Flemisch  F,  Kelsch  J,  Löper  C,  et  al.  Cooperative  control  and active  interfaces  for  vehicle  assitsance  and  automation  // FISITA World Automotive Congress. München, 2008 [7] Hu Y F, Qu T, Liu J, et al. Human-machine cooperative control of intelligent  vehicle:  recent  developments  and  future  perspectives. Acta Autom Sin, 2019, 45（7）: 1261 （胡云峰, 曲婷, 刘俊, 等. 智能汽车人机协同控制的研究现状与 展望. 自动化学报, 2019, 45（7）：1261） [8] Guo  L,  Li  L  H. Vehicle Driving Safety Assistance Technology. Beijing: Peking University Press, 2014 （郭烈, 李琳辉. 汽车安全辅助驾驶技术. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2014） [9] ISO  17361 —2017. Intelligent Transportation Systems –Lane Departure Warning Systems–Performance Requirements and Test Procedures. London: British Standards Institution, 2017 [10] Lin  C  F,  Ulsoy  A  G.  Time  to  lane  crossing  calculation  and characterization of its associated uncertainty. Intell Transp Syst J, 1996, 3（2）: 85 [11] Chang T H, Hsu C S, Wang C, et al. Onboard measurement and warning module for irregular vehicle behavior. IEEE Trans Intell Transp Syst, 2008, 9（3）: 501 [12] Falcone  P,  Ali  M,  Sjöberg  J.  Predictive  threat  assessment  via reachability analysis and set invariance theory. IEEE Trans Intell Transp Syst, 2011, 12（4）: 1352 [13] Li  X  P,  Seignez  E,  Loonis  P,  et  al.  Vision-based  estimation  of driving  inattention  fused via Dempster-Shafer  theory  // IEEE International Conference on Cyber Technology in Automation, Control, & Intelligent Systems. Bangkok, 2012: 393 [14] Nalla  P,  Goud  G  C  L  A,  Padmaja  V.  Accident  avoiding  system using lane detection. Int J Rev Electron Commun Eng, 2013, 1（1）: 1 [15] Batavia  P  H. Driver-Adaptive Lane Departure Warning Systems. Pittsburgh: Carnegie Mellon University, 1999 [16] Jung  C  R,  Kelber  C  R.  A  lane  departure  warning  system  using lateral offset with uncalibrated camera // Intelligent Transportation Systems. Vienna, 2005: 102 [17] Liu  X  H. Development of A Vision-Based Object Detection and Recognition System for Intelligent Vehicle [Dissertation]. Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2000 [18] Wu  D  H,  Ye  X  J,  Gu  W  K.  An  uncertain  knowledge  based  real time  road  scene  understanding  algorithm. J Image Graph,  2002, 7（1）: 69 （吴东晖, 叶秀清, 顾伟康. 基于不确定性知识的实时道路场景 理解. 中国图象图形学报, 2002, 7（1）：69） [19] Gonzalez-Mendoza  M,  Jammes  B,  Hernandez-Gress  N,  et  al.  A comparison  of  road  departure  warning  systems  on  real  driving conditions  //  7th International IEEE Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems. Washington, 2004: 349 [20] Zhou  Y,  Xu  R,  Hu  X  F,  et  al.  A  lane  departure  warning  system based on virtual lane boundary. J Inf Sci Eng, 2008, 24（1）: 293 [21] Godthelp H, Milgram P, Blaauw G J. The development of a time￾related  measure  to  describe  driving  strategy. Human Factors, 1984, 26（3）: 257 [22] Enkelmann  W.  Video-based  driver  assistance  -  from  basic functions to applications. Int J Comput Vision, 2001, 45（3）: 201 [23] Xu L H, Luo Q, Zhang L Y, et al. Research on variable virtual lane boundary for lane departure warning systems. Adv Transp Studies, 2014, 32: 37 [24] [25] Zhang  W  W,  Song  X  L,  Zhang  G  X.  Real-Time  lane  departure · 362 · 工程科学学报，第 43 卷，第 3 期