THE JOURNAL OF FINANCE.VOL.LI,NO.1.MARCH 1996 Multifactor Explanations of Asset Pricing Anomalies EUGENE F.FAMA and KENNETH R.FRENCH* ABSTRACT Previous work shows that average returns on common stocks are related to firm characteristics like size,earnings/price,cash flow/price,book-to-market equity,past sales growth,long-term past return,and short-term past return.Because these patterns in average returns apparently are not explained by the CAPM,they are called anomalies.We find that,except for the continuation of short-term returns,the anomalies largely disappear in a three-factor model.Our results are consistent with rational ICAPM or APT asset pricing,but we also consider irrational pricing and data problems as possible explanations. RESEARCHERS HAVE IDENTIFIED MANY patterns in average stock returns.For ex- ample,DeBondt and Thaler(1985)find a reversal in long-term returns;stocks with low long-term past returns tend to have higher future returns.In con- trast,Jegadeesh and Titman (1993)find that short-term returns tend to continue;stocks with higher returns in the previous twelve months tend to have higher future returns.Others show that a firm's average stock return is related to its size (ME,stock price times number of shares),book-to-market- equity (BE/ME,the ratio of the book value of common equity to its market value),earnings/price(E/P),cash flow/price(C/P),and past sales growth.(Banz (1981),Basu(1983),Rosenberg,Reid,and Lanstein(1985),and Lakonishok, Shleifer and Vishny (1994).)Because these patterns in average stock returns are not explained by the capital asset pricing model(CAPM)of Sharpe(1964) and Lintner(1965),they are typically called anomalies. This paper argues that many of the CAPM average-return anomalies are related,and they are captured by the three-factor model in Fama and French (FF 1993).The model says that the expected return on a portfolio in excess of the risk-free rate [E(R)-Rel is explained by the sensitivity of its return to three factors:(i)the excess return on a broad market portfolio(R-R;(ii) the difference between the return on a portfolio of small stocks and the return on a portfolio of large stocks (SMB,small minus big);and (iii)the difference between the return on a portfolio of high-book-to-market stocks and the return on a portfolio of low-book-to-market stocks (HML,high minus low).Specifi- cally,the expected excess return on portfolio iis, E(R)-R=bE(RM)-R]+sE(SMB)+hE(HML), (1) Fama is from the Graduate School of Business,University of Chicago,and French is from the Yale School of Management,The comments of Clifford Asness,John Cochrane,Josef Lakonishok, G.William Schwert,and Rene Stulz are gratefully acknowledged. 55