Peer-Review and Revision Does the method include participants/materials, instruments,data collection and analysis? Do the figures and tables have titles?Are the tables 4 and figures placed appropriately?Are they referred to and described in the text?Is there a citation if the table or figure is from some other research? Are the results explained and analyzed with good reasons,and compared with other research? Does the conclusion involve the summary of arguments,findings,implications,limitations and further studies?Peer-Review and Revision Do the figures and tables have titles? Are the tables and figures placed appropriately? Are they referred to and described in the text? Is there a citation if the table or figure is from some other research? Are the results explained and analyzed with good reasons, and compared with other research? Does the conclusion involve the summary of arguments, findings, implications, limitations and further studies? 16 15 14 13 Does the method include participants/materials, instruments, data collection and analysis?