CHALMERS(1996)OFFERS A PARODY (s 笑模仿) o 1. Programs are purely o 1. Recipes are syntactic formal (syntactic) o 2. Human minds have o 2. Cakes are crumbly mental contents (semantics) o 3. Syntax by itself is o 3. Syntax is not neither constitutive of sufficient for nor sufficient for crumbliness semantic content o 4. Therefore, programs by themselves are not o 4. Implementation of a constitutive of nor recipe is not sufficient sufficient for minds for making a cakeCHALMERS (1996) OFFERS A PARODY (搞 笑模仿): 1. Programs are purely formal (syntactic). 2. Human minds have mental contents (semantics). 3. Syntax by itself is neither constitutive of, nor sufficient for, semantic content. 4. Therefore, programs by themselves are not constitutive of nor sufficient for minds. 1.Recipes are syntactic. 2.Cakes are crumbly. 3. Syntax is not sufficient for crumbliness. 4. Implementation of a recipe is not sufficient for making a cake