504 Chapter 12.Fast Fourier Transform The discrete form of Parseval's theorem is N-1 N-1 (12.1.10) k=0 刀=0 There are also discrete analogs to the convolution and correlation theorems(equations 12.0.9 and 12.0.11),but we shall defer them to $13.1 and $13.2,respectively. CITED REFERENCES AND FURTHER READING: 三 Brigham,E.O.1974,The Fast Fourier Transform(Englewood Cliffs,NJ:Prentice-Hall). Elliott,D.F.,and Rao,K.R.1982,Fast Transforms:Algorithms,Analyses,Applications (New York: Academic Press). 、意轮 12.2 Fast Fourier Transform(FFT) How much computation is involved in computing the discrete Fourier transform (12.1.7)of N points?For many years,until the mid-1960s,the standard answer 平空> Press. was this:Define W as the complex number W三e2m/N (12.2.1) Then (12.1.7)can be written as IENTIFIC 61 N-1 Hn= wnkhk (12.2.2) k=0 In other words,the vector of hk's is multiplied by a matrix whose(n,k)th element is the constant W to the power n x k.The matrix multiplication produces a vector 10.621 result whose components are the A,'s.This matrix multiplication evidently requires Numerica N2 complex multiplications,plus a smaller number of operations to generate the 431 required powers of W.So,the discrete Fourier transform appears to be an O(N2) Recipes process.These appearances are deceiving!The discrete Fourier transform can, in fact,be computed in O(N log2 N)operations with an algorithm called the fast (outside Fourier transform,or FFT.The difference between Nlog2 N and N2 is immense. North With N =106,for example,it is the difference between,roughly,30 seconds of CPU time and 2 weeks of CPU time on a microsecond cycle time computer.The existence of an FFT algorithm became generally known only in the mid-1960s,from the work of J.W.Cooley and J.W.Tukey.Retrospectively,we now know (see [11)that efficient methods for computing the DFT had been independently discovered.and in some cases implemented,by as many as a dozen individuals,starting with Gauss in 1805! One"rediscovery"of the FFT,that of Danielson and Lanczos in 1942,provides one of the clearest derivations of the algorithm.Danielson and Lanczos showed that a discrete Fourier transform of length N can be rewritten as the sum of two discrete Fourier transforms,each of length N/2.One of the two is formed from the
504 Chapter 12. Fast Fourier Transform Permission is granted for internet users to make one paper copy for their own personal use. Further reproduction, or any copyin Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. Programs Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes Software. Sample page from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: THE ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN 0-521-43108-5) g of machinereadable files (including this one) to any server computer, is strictly prohibited. To order Numerical Recipes books or CDROMs, visit website http://www.nr.com or call 1-800-872-7423 (North America only), or send email to directcustserv@cambridge.org (outside North America). The discrete form of Parseval’s theorem is N −1 k=0 |hk| 2 = 1 N N −1 n=0 |Hn| 2 (12.1.10) There are also discrete analogs to the convolution and correlation theorems (equations 12.0.9 and 12.0.11), but we shall defer them to §13.1 and §13.2, respectively. CITED REFERENCES AND FURTHER READING: Brigham, E.O. 1974, The Fast Fourier Transform (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall). Elliott, D.F., and Rao, K.R. 1982, Fast Transforms: Algorithms, Analyses, Applications (New York: Academic Press). 12.2 Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) How much computation is involved in computing the discrete Fourier transform (12.1.7) of N points? For many years, until the mid-1960s, the standard answer was this: Define W as the complex number W ≡ e2πi/N (12.2.1) Then (12.1.7) can be written as Hn = N −1 k=0 Wnkhk (12.2.2) In other words, the vector of hk’s is multiplied by a matrix whose (n, k)th element is the constant W to the power n × k. The matrix multiplication produces a vector result whose components are the Hn’s. This matrix multiplication evidently requires N2 complex multiplications, plus a smaller number of operations to generate the required powers of W. So, the discrete Fourier transform appears to be an O(N 2) process. These appearances are deceiving! The discrete Fourier transform can, in fact, be computed in O(N log2 N) operations with an algorithm called the fast Fourier transform, or FFT. The difference between N log2 N and N2 is immense. With N = 106, for example, it is the difference between, roughly, 30 seconds of CPU time and 2 weeks of CPU time on a microsecond cycle time computer. The existence of an FFT algorithm became generally known only in the mid-1960s, from the work of J.W. Cooley and J.W. Tukey. Retrospectively, we now know (see [1]) that efficient methods for computing the DFT had been independently discovered, and in some cases implemented, by as many as a dozen individuals, starting with Gauss in 1805! One “rediscovery” of the FFT, that of Danielson and Lanczos in 1942, provides one of the clearest derivations of the algorithm. Danielson and Lanczos showed that a discrete Fourier transform of length N can be rewritten as the sum of two discrete Fourier transforms, each of length N/2. One of the two is formed from the
12.2 Fast Fourier Transform(FFT) 505 even-numbered points of the original N,the other from the odd-numbered points. The proof is simply this: -1 Fk= 2rik/Nf方 j=0 N/2- N/2-1 ∑e2aie/f+ 2ik(2j+1)/N f2j+1 j= 1=0 (12.2.3) N/2-1 N/2-1 e2xikj/(N/2)f23 +Wk e2ikj/(N2)f2j+1 83 j=0 j=0 =F+WF阳 g In the last line,W is the same complex constant as in (12.2.1),Fe denotes the kth component of the Fourier transform of length N/2 formed from the even components of the original fi's,while Fe is the corresponding transform of length N/2 formed from the odd components.Notice also that k in the last line of(12.2.3)varies from 9 0 to N,not just to N/2.Nevertheless,the transforms Fe and F are periodic in k with length N/2.So each is repeated through two cycles to obtain F The wonderful thing about the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma is that it can be used recursively.Having reduced the problem of computing F&to that of computing Fe and Fe,we can do the same reduction of Fe to the problem of computing 孕芝%0 9 the transform of its N/4 even-numbered input data and N/4 odd-numbered data. In other words,we can define Fee and Feo to be the discrete Fourier transforms of the points which are respectively even-even and even-odd on the successive subdivisions of the data. Although there are ways of treating other cases,by far the easiest case is the one in which the original N is an integer power of 2.In fact,we categorically recommend that you only use FFTs with N a power of two.If the length of your data set is not a power of two,pad it with zeros up to the next power of two.(We will give more sophisticated suggestions in subsequent sections below.)With this restriction g今 6 10-521 on N,it is evident that we can continue applying the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma Numerica until we have subdivided the data all the way down to transforms of length 1.What 43106 is the Fourier transform of length one?It is just the identity operation that copies its one input number into its one output slot!In other words,for every pattern of log2 N e's and o's,there is a one-point transform that is just one of the input numbers fn Peoceoeo.…oee=fn for some n (12.2.4) (Of course this one-point transform actually does not depend on k,since it is periodic in k with period 1.) The next trick is to figure out which value of n corresponds to which pattern of e's and o's in equation(12.2.4).The answer is:Reverse the pattern of e's and o's, then let e =0 and o =1,and you will have,in binary the value of n.Do you see why it works?It is because the successive subdivisions of the data into even and odd are tests of successive low-order (least significant)bits of n.This idea of bit reversal can be exploited in a very clever way which,along with the Danielson-Lanczos
12.2 Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) 505 Permission is granted for internet users to make one paper copy for their own personal use. Further reproduction, or any copyin Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. Programs Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes Software. Sample page from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: THE ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN 0-521-43108-5) g of machinereadable files (including this one) to any server computer, is strictly prohibited. To order Numerical Recipes books or CDROMs, visit website http://www.nr.com or call 1-800-872-7423 (North America only), or send email to directcustserv@cambridge.org (outside North America). even-numbered points of the original N, the other from the odd-numbered points. The proof is simply this: Fk = N −1 j=0 e2πijk/N fj = N/ 2−1 j=0 e2πik(2j)/N f2j + N/ 2−1 j=0 e2πik(2j+1)/N f2j+1 = N/ 2−1 j=0 e2πikj/(N/2)f2j + Wk N/ 2−1 j=0 e2πikj/(N/2)f2j+1 = Fe k + Wk Fo k (12.2.3) In the last line, W is the same complex constant as in (12.2.1), F e k denotes the kth component of the Fourier transform of length N/2 formed from the even components of the original fj ’s, while Fo k is the corresponding transform of length N/2 formed from the odd components. Notice also that k in the last line of (12.2.3) varies from 0 to N, not just to N/2. Nevertheless, the transforms F e k and Fo k are periodic in k with length N/2. So each is repeated through two cycles to obtain Fk. The wonderful thing about the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma is that it can be used recursively. Having reduced the problem of computing Fk to that of computing Fe k and Fo k , we can do the same reduction of F e k to the problem of computing the transform of its N/4 even-numbered input data and N/4 odd-numbered data. In other words, we can define F ee k and Feo k to be the discrete Fourier transforms of the points which are respectively even-even and even-odd on the successive subdivisions of the data. Although there are ways of treating other cases, by far the easiest case is the one in which the original N is an integer power of 2. In fact, we categorically recommend that you only use FFTs with N a power of two. If the length of your data set is not a power of two, pad it with zeros up to the next power of two. (We will give more sophisticated suggestions in subsequent sections below.) With this restriction on N, it is evident that we can continue applying the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma until we have subdivided the data all the way down to transforms of length 1. What is the Fourier transform of length one? It is just the identity operation that copies its one input number into its one output slot! In other words, for every pattern of log 2 N e’s and o’s, there is a one-point transform that is just one of the input numbers f n Feoeeoeo···oee k = fn for some n (12.2.4) (Of course this one-point transform actually does not depend on k, since it is periodic in k with period 1.) The next trick is to figure out which value of n corresponds to which pattern of e’s and o’s in equation (12.2.4). The answer is: Reverse the pattern of e’s and o’s, then let e = 0 and o = 1, and you will have, in binary the value of n. Do you see why it works? It is because the successive subdivisions of the data into even and odd are tests of successive low-order (least significant) bits of n. This idea of bit reversal can be exploited in a very clever way which, along with the Danielson-Lanczos
506 Chapter 12. Fast Fourier Transform 000 000 000 001 001 001 010 010 010 011 011 011 100 100 100 Permission is read able files 101 101 101 110 110 110 .com or call granted fori 111 111 111 (including this one) (a) (b) 111800-672 19881992y0的e 19 Figure 12.2.1.Reordering an array (here of length 8)by bit reversal,(a)between two arrays,versus(b) from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: in place.Bit reversal reordering is a necessary part of the fast Fourier transform(FFT)algorithm. (North Lemma,makes FFTs practical:Suppose we take the original vector of data fi America 州bMe se tusers to make one paper UnN电.t THE and rearrange it into bit-reversed order(see Figure 12.2.1),so that the individual 是 ART numbers are in the order not ofj,but of the number obtained by bit-reversing j. Then the bookkeeping on the recursive application of the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma ictly proh Programs becomes extraordinarily simple.The points as given are the one-point transforms. We combine adjacent pairs to get two-point transforms,then combine adjacent pairs of pairs to get 4-point transforms,and so on,until the first and second halves of the whole data set are combined into the final transform.Each combination takes to dir of order N operations,and there are evidently log2 N combinations,so the whole algorithm is of order Nlog2 N(assuming,as is the case,that the process of sorting OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN into bit-reversed order is no greater in order than Nlog2 N). 1988-19920 This,then,is the structure of an FFT algorithm:It has two sections.The first section sorts the data into bit-reversed order.Luckily this takes no additional storage, 10-521 since it involves only swapping pairs of elements.(If is the bit reverse of k2,then k2 is the bit reverse of k1.)The second section has an outer loop that is executed log2 N times and calculates,in turn,transforms of length 2,4,8,...,N.For each Numerical Recipes 431985 stage of this process,two nested inner loops range over the subtransforms already computed and the elements ofeach transform,implementing the Danielson-Lanczos (outside Lemma.The operation is made more efficient by restricting external calls for North Software. trigonometric sines and cosines to the outer loop,where they are made only log2 N times.Computation of the sines and cosines of multiple angles is through simple recurrence relations in the inner loops(cf.5.5.6). visit website The FFT routine given below is based on one originally written by N.M. machine Brenner.The input quantities are the number of complex data points(nn),the data array(data[1..2*nn]),and isign,which should be set to either +1 and is the sign of i in the exponential of equation(12.1.7).When isign is set to-1,the routine thus calculates the inverse transform (12.1.9)-except that it does not multiply by the normalizing factor 1/N that appears in that equation.You can do that yourself. Notice that the argument nn is the number of complex data points.The actual
506 Chapter 12. Fast Fourier Transform Permission is granted for internet users to make one paper copy for their own personal use. Further reproduction, or any copyin Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. Programs Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes Software. Sample page from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: THE ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN 0-521-43108-5) g of machinereadable files (including this one) to any server computer, is strictly prohibited. To order Numerical Recipes books or CDROMs, visit website http://www.nr.com or call 1-800-872-7423 (North America only), or send email to directcustserv@cambridge.org (outside North America). 000 001 010 011 100 101 110 111 000 001 010 011 100 101 110 111 000 001 010 011 100 101 110 111 (a) (b) Figure 12.2.1. Reordering an array (here of length 8) by bit reversal, (a) between two arrays, versus (b) in place. Bit reversal reordering is a necessary part of the fast Fourier transform (FFT) algorithm. Lemma, makes FFTs practical: Suppose we take the original vector of data f j and rearrange it into bit-reversed order (see Figure 12.2.1), so that the individual numbers are in the order not of j, but of the number obtained by bit-reversing j. Then the bookkeeping on the recursive application of the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma becomes extraordinarily simple. The points as given are the one-point transforms. We combine adjacent pairs to get two-point transforms, then combine adjacent pairs of pairs to get 4-point transforms, and so on, until the first and second halves of the whole data set are combined into the final transform. Each combination takes of order N operations, and there are evidently log 2 N combinations, so the whole algorithm is of order N log2 N (assuming, as is the case, that the process of sorting into bit-reversed order is no greater in order than N log 2 N). This, then, is the structure of an FFT algorithm: It has two sections. The first section sorts the data into bit-reversed order. Luckily this takes no additional storage, since it involves only swapping pairs of elements. (If k 1 is the bit reverse of k2, then k2 is the bit reverse of k1.) The second section has an outer loop that is executed log2 N times and calculates, in turn, transforms of length 2, 4, 8,...,N. For each stage of this process, two nested inner loops range over the subtransforms already computed and the elements of each transform, implementing the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma. The operation is made more efficient by restricting external calls for trigonometric sines and cosines to the outer loop, where they are made only log 2 N times. Computation of the sines and cosines of multiple angles is through simple recurrence relations in the inner loops (cf. 5.5.6). The FFT routine given below is based on one originally written by N. M. Brenner. The input quantities are the number of complex data points (nn), the data array (data[1..2*nn]), and isign, which should be set to either ±1 and is the sign of i in the exponential of equation (12.1.7). When isign is set to −1, the routine thus calculates the inverse transform (12.1.9) — except that it does not multiply by the normalizing factor 1/N that appears in that equation. You can do that yourself. Notice that the argument nn is the number of complex data points. The actual
12.2 Fast Fourier Transform(FFT) 507 length of the real array (data[1..2*nn])is 2 times nn.with each complex value occupying two consecutive locations.In other words,data[]is the real part of fo,data[2]is the imaginary part of fo,and so on up to data[2*nn-1],which is the real part of fN-1,and data[2*nn],which is the imaginary part of fN-1. The FFT routine gives back the Fn's packed in exactly the same fashion,as nn complex numbers. The real and imaginary parts ofthe zero frequency component Foare in data[1] and data[2];the smallest nonzero positive frequency has real and imaginary parts in data[3]and data [4]:the smallest (in magnitude)nonzero negative frequency has real and imaginary parts in data[2*nn-1]and data[2*nn].Positive frequencies 8 increasing in magnitude are stored in the real-imaginary pairs data [5],data [6] up to data[nn-1],data [nn].Negative frequencies of increasing magnitude are stored in data[2*nn-3],data[2*nn-2]down to data [nn+3],data [nn+4] Finally,the pair data[nn+1],data [nn+2]contain the real and imaginary parts of the one aliased point that contains the most positive and the most negative frequency. You should try to develop a familiarity with this storage arrangement of complex from NUMERICAL RECIPES I 18881892 spectra,also shown in Figure 12.2.2,since it is the practical standard. This is a good place to remind you that you can also use a routine like four1 without modification even if your input data array is zero-offset,that is has the range data[o..2*nn-1].In this case,simply decrement the pointer to data by one when Press. THE four1 is invoked,e.g.,four1(data-1,1024,1);.The real part of fo will now be ART returned in data[o],the imaginary part in data[1],and so on.See 81.2. 9 #include Program #define SWAP(a,b)tempr=(a);(a)=(b);(b)=tempr void fouri(float data[],unsigned long nn,int isign) Replaces data[1..2*nn]by its discrete Fourier transform,if isign is input as 1;or replaces data[1..2*nn]by nn times its inverse discrete Fourier transform,if isign is input as -1. data is a complex array of length nn or,equivalently,a real array of length 2*nn.nn MUST be an integer power of 2 (this is not checked for!). OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING(ISBN unsigned long n,mmax,m,j,istep,i; 198918920 double wtemp,wr,wpr,wpi,wi,theta; Double precision for the trigonomet- float tempr,tempi; ric recurrences. Numerical Recipes 10-621 n=nn1)[ routine. SWAP(data[i],data[i]); Exchange the two complex numbers. SWAP(data[j+1],data[i+1]); (outside 膜 Software. menn: wh11e(m>=2&j>m){ j-=m; m>>=1; j+=m; Here begins the Danielson-Lanczos section of the routine. mmax=2: while (n mmax){ Outer loop executed log2 nn times. istep=mmax <1; theta=is1gn*(6.28318530717959/mmax); Initialize the trigonometric recurrence. wtemp=sin(0.5*theta); wpr =-2.0*wtemp*wtemp;
12.2 Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) 507 Permission is granted for internet users to make one paper copy for their own personal use. Further reproduction, or any copyin Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. Programs Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes Software. Sample page from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: THE ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN 0-521-43108-5) g of machinereadable files (including this one) to any server computer, is strictly prohibited. To order Numerical Recipes books or CDROMs, visit website http://www.nr.com or call 1-800-872-7423 (North America only), or send email to directcustserv@cambridge.org (outside North America). length of the real array (data[1..2*nn]) is 2 times nn, with each complex value occupying two consecutive locations. In other words, data[1] is the real part of f0, data[2] is the imaginary part of f0, and so on up to data[2*nn-1], which is the real part of fN−1, and data[2*nn], which is the imaginary part of fN−1. The FFT routine gives back the Fn’s packed in exactly the same fashion, as nn complex numbers. The real and imaginary parts of the zero frequency component F 0 are in data[1] and data[2]; the smallest nonzero positive frequency has real and imaginary parts in data[3] and data[4]; the smallest (in magnitude) nonzero negative frequency has real and imaginary parts in data[2*nn-1] and data[2*nn]. Positive frequencies increasing in magnitude are stored in the real-imaginary pairs data[5], data[6] up to data[nn-1], data[nn]. Negative frequencies of increasing magnitude are stored in data[2*nn-3], data[2*nn-2] down to data[nn+3], data[nn+4]. Finally, the pair data[nn+1], data[nn+2] contain the real and imaginary parts of the one aliased point that contains the most positive and the most negative frequency. You should try to develop a familiarity with this storage arrangement of complex spectra, also shown in Figure 12.2.2, since it is the practical standard. This is a good place to remind you that you can also use a routine like four1 without modification even if your input data array is zero-offset, that is has the range data[0..2*nn-1]. In this case, simply decrement the pointer to data by one when four1 is invoked, e.g., four1(data-1,1024,1);. The real part of f0 will now be returned in data[0], the imaginary part in data[1], and so on. See §1.2. #include #define SWAP(a,b) tempr=(a);(a)=(b);(b)=tempr void four1(float data[], unsigned long nn, int isign) Replaces data[1..2*nn] by its discrete Fourier transform, if isign is input as 1; or replaces data[1..2*nn] by nn times its inverse discrete Fourier transform, if isign is input as −1. data is a complex array of length nn or, equivalently, a real array of length 2*nn. nn MUST be an integer power of 2 (this is not checked for!). { unsigned long n,mmax,m,j,istep,i; double wtemp,wr,wpr,wpi,wi,theta; Double precision for the trigonometfloat tempr,tempi; ric recurrences. n=nn i) { routine. SWAP(data[j],data[i]); Exchange the two complex numbers. SWAP(data[j+1],data[i+1]); } m=nn; while (m >= 2 && j > m) { j -= m; m >>= 1; } j += m; } Here begins the Danielson-Lanczos section of the routine. mmax=2; while (n > mmax) { Outer loop executed log2 nn times. istep=mmax << 1; theta=isign*(6.28318530717959/mmax); Initialize the trigonometric recurrence. wtemp=sin(0.5*theta); wpr = -2.0*wtemp*wtemp;
508 Chapter 12.Fast Fourier Transform ①real ①real 1=0 r=0 imag ② imag real real 1 1=△ f= (④imag imag N△ Permission is read able files -D real f= N2-1 http://www.nr.com or imag N△ +D real (combination) N+2 imag ∫=±2 11-800 (including this one) granted fori N+3 real f=- N/2-1 N+imag N△ from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN 2N-3 real 1=(N-2)△ 2N-2 imag (North America to any server computer, tusers to make one paper 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. THE 2w-①real 2N-D real t=(N-1)△ 1 N ④ imag N△ 是 Programs (a) (b) send Figure 12.2.2.Input and output arrays for FFT.(a)The input array contains N (a power of 2) strictly prohibited complex time samples in a real array of length 2N,with real and imaginary parts altemating.(b)The output array contains the complex Fourier spectrum at N values of frequency.Real and imaginary parts to dir Copyright (C) again alternate.The array starts with zero frequency,works up to the most positive frequency (which is ambiguous with the most negative frequency).Negative frequencies follow,from the second-most negative up to the frequency just below zero. ectcustser ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING(ISBN wpi=sin(theta); wr=1.0; v@cam w1=0.0; 10-621 for (m=1;m<mmax;m+=2){ Here are the two nested inner loops. for (i=m;i<=n;i+=istep) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes j=i+mmax; This is the Danielson-Lanczos for- 43108-5 tempr-wr*data[j]-wi*data[j+1]; mula: tempi=wr*data[j+1]+wi*data[j]; data[j]=data [i]-tempr; (outside data[j+1]=data[i+1]-tempi; data[i]tempr; North Software. data[i+1]+tempi; wr=(wtemp=wr)*wpr-wi*wpi+wr; Trigonometric recurrence. America) wi=wi*wpr+wtemp*wpi+wi; mmax=istep; (A double precision version of four1,named dfour1,is used by the routine mpmul in $20.6.You can easily make the conversion,or else get the converted routine from the Numerical Recipes diskette
508 Chapter 12. Fast Fourier Transform Permission is granted for internet users to make one paper copy for their own personal use. Further reproduction, or any copyin Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. Programs Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes Software. Sample page from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: THE ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN 0-521-43108-5) g of machinereadable files (including this one) to any server computer, is strictly prohibited. To order Numerical Recipes books or CDROMs, visit website http://www.nr.com or call 1-800-872-7423 (North America only), or send email to directcustserv@cambridge.org (outside North America). 1 2 3 4 real imag real imag t = 0 t = ∆ real imag real imag t = (N − 2)∆ t = (N − 1)∆ real array of length 2 N 1 2 3 4 real imag real imag f = 0 f = N − 1 N N + 1 N + 2 N + 3 N + 4 real imag real imag real imag f = f = ± (combination) f = − real array of length 2 N 1 N∆ N/2 − 1 N∆ 1 2∆ 2N − 1 2N real imag f = − 1 N∆ 2N − 3 2N − 2 2N − 1 2N N/2 − 1 N∆ (a) (b) Figure 12.2.2. Input and output arrays for FFT. (a) The input array contains N (a power of 2) complex time samples in a real array of length 2N, with real and imaginary parts alternating. (b) The output array contains the complex Fourier spectrum at N values of frequency. Real and imaginary parts again alternate. The array starts with zero frequency, works up to the most positive frequency (which is ambiguous with the most negative frequency). Negative frequencies follow, from the second-most negative up to the frequency just below zero. wpi=sin(theta); wr=1.0; wi=0.0; for (m=1;m<mmax;m+=2) { Here are the two nested inner loops. for (i=m;i<=n;i+=istep) { j=i+mmax; This is the Danielson-Lanczos fortempr=wr*data[j]-wi*data[j+1]; mula: tempi=wr*data[j+1]+wi*data[j]; data[j]=data[i]-tempr; data[j+1]=data[i+1]-tempi; data[i] += tempr; data[i+1] += tempi; } wr=(wtemp=wr)*wpr-wi*wpi+wr; Trigonometric recurrence. wi=wi*wpr+wtemp*wpi+wi; } mmax=istep; } } (A double precision version of four1, named dfour1, is used by the routine mpmul in §20.6. You can easily make the conversion, or else get the converted routine from the Numerical Recipes diskette.)
12.2 Fast Fourier Transform(FFT) 509 Other FFT Algorithms We should mention that there are anumber of variants on the basic FFT algorithm given above.As we have seen,that algorithm first rearranges the input elements into bit-reverse order,then builds up the output transform in log2 N iterations.In the literature,this sequence is called a decimation-in-time or Cooley-Tukey FFT algorithm.It is also possible to derive FFT algorithms that first go through a set of log2 N iterations on the input data,and rearrange the output values into bit-reverse order.These are called decimation-in-frequencyor Sande-Tukey FFT algorithms.For some applications,such as convolution(13.1),one takes a data set into the Fourier domain and then,after some manipulation,back out again.In these cases it is possible g to avoid all bit reversing.You use a decimation-in-frequency algorithm (without its bit reversing)to get into the "scrambled"Fourier domain,do your operations there, and then use an inverse algorithm(without its bit reversing)to get back to the time domain.While elegant in principle,this procedure does not in practice save much computation time,since the bit reversals represent only a small fraction of an FFT's operations count,and since most useful operations in the frequency domain require a knowledge of which points correspond to which frequencies. 9 Another class of FFTs subdivides the initial data set of length N not all the way down to the trivial transform of length 1,but rather only down to some other small power of 2,for example N =4,base-4 FFTs,or N=8,base-8 FFTs.These small transforms are then done by small sections of highly optimized coding which take advantage of special symmetries of that particular small N.For example,for 套是会 9 N =4,the trigonometric sines and cosines that enter are all +1 or 0,so many multiplications are eliminated,leaving largely additions and subtractions.These can be faster than simpler FFTs by some significant,but not overwhelming,factor, e.g,20 or 30 percent. 6 There are also FFT algorithms for data sets oflength N not a power oftwo.They work by using relations analogous to the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma to subdivide the initial problem into successively smaller problems,not by factors of 2.but by whatever small prime factors happen to divide N.The larger that the largest prime factor of N is,the worse this method works.If N is prime,then no subdivision is possible,and the user (whether he knows it or not)is taking a slow Fourier transform,of order N2 instead of order Nlog2 N.Our advice is to stay clear W、 Numerical Recipes 10621 43106 of such FFT implementations,with perhaps one class of exceptions,the Winograd Fourier transform algorithms.Winograd algorithms are in some ways analogous to the base-4 and base-8 FFTs.Winograd has derived highly optimized codings for (outside taking small-N discrete Fourier transforms,e.g.,for N =2,3,4,5,7,8,11,13,16. North The algorithms also use a new and clever way of combining the subfactors.The method involves a reordering of the data both before the hierarchical processing and after it,but it allows a significant reduction in the number of multiplications in the algorithm.For some especially favorable values of N,the Winograd algorithms can be significantly (e.g.,up to a factor of 2)faster than the simpler FFT algorithms of the nearest integer power of 2.This advantage in speed,however,must be weighed against the considerably more complicated data indexing involved in these transforms,and the fact that the Winograd transform cannot be done"in place." Finally,an interesting class of transforms for doing convolutions quickly are number theoretic transforms.These schemes replace floating-point arithmetic with
12.2 Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) 509 Permission is granted for internet users to make one paper copy for their own personal use. Further reproduction, or any copyin Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. Programs Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes Software. Sample page from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: THE ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN 0-521-43108-5) g of machinereadable files (including this one) to any server computer, is strictly prohibited. To order Numerical Recipes books or CDROMs, visit website http://www.nr.com or call 1-800-872-7423 (North America only), or send email to directcustserv@cambridge.org (outside North America). Other FFT Algorithms We should mention that there are a number of variants on the basic FFT algorithm given above. As we have seen, that algorithm first rearranges the input elements into bit-reverse order, then builds up the output transform in log 2 N iterations. In the literature, this sequence is called a decimation-in-time or Cooley-Tukey FFT algorithm. It is also possible to derive FFT algorithms that first go through a set of log2 N iterations on the input data, and rearrange the output values into bit-reverse order. These are called decimation-in-frequencyor Sande-Tukey FFT algorithms. For some applications, such as convolution (§13.1), one takes a data set into the Fourier domain and then, after some manipulation, back out again. In these cases it is possible to avoid all bit reversing. You use a decimation-in-frequency algorithm (without its bit reversing) to get into the “scrambled” Fourier domain, do your operations there, and then use an inverse algorithm (without its bit reversing) to get back to the time domain. While elegant in principle, this procedure does not in practice save much computation time, since the bit reversals represent only a small fraction of an FFT’s operations count, and since most useful operations in the frequency domain require a knowledge of which points correspond to which frequencies. Another class of FFTs subdivides the initial data set of length N not all the way down to the trivial transform of length 1, but rather only down to some other small power of 2, for example N = 4, base-4 FFTs, or N = 8, base-8 FFTs. These small transforms are then done by small sections of highly optimized coding which take advantage of special symmetries of that particular small N. For example, for N = 4, the trigonometric sines and cosines that enter are all ±1 or 0, so many multiplications are eliminated, leaving largely additions and subtractions. These can be faster than simpler FFTs by some significant, but not overwhelming, factor, e.g., 20 or 30 percent. There are also FFT algorithms for data sets of length N not a power of two. They work by using relations analogous to the Danielson-Lanczos Lemma to subdivide the initial problem into successively smaller problems, not by factors of 2, but by whatever small prime factors happen to divide N. The larger that the largest prime factor of N is, the worse this method works. If N is prime, then no subdivision is possible, and the user (whether he knows it or not) is taking a slow Fourier transform, of order N 2 instead of order N log2 N. Our advice is to stay clear of such FFT implementations, with perhaps one class of exceptions, the Winograd Fourier transform algorithms. Winograd algorithms are in some ways analogous to the base-4 and base-8 FFTs. Winograd has derived highly optimized codings for taking small-N discrete Fourier transforms, e.g., for N = 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 11, 13, 16. The algorithms also use a new and clever way of combining the subfactors. The method involves a reordering of the data both before the hierarchical processing and after it, but it allows a significant reduction in the number of multiplications in the algorithm. For some especially favorable values of N, the Winograd algorithms can be significantly (e.g., up to a factor of 2) faster than the simpler FFT algorithms of the nearest integer power of 2. This advantage in speed, however, must be weighed against the considerably more complicated data indexing involved in these transforms, and the fact that the Winograd transform cannot be done “in place.” Finally, an interesting class of transforms for doing convolutions quickly are number theoretic transforms. These schemes replace floating-point arithmetic with
510 Chapter 12.Fast Fourier Transform integer arithmetic modulo some large prime N+1,and the Nth root of 1 by the modulo arithmetic equivalent.Strictly speaking,these are not Fourier transforms at all,but the properties are quite similar and computational speed can be far superior.On the other hand,their use is somewhat restricted to quantities like correlations and convolutions since the transform itself is not easily interpretable asa“frequency”spectrum. CITED REFERENCES AND FURTHER READING: Nussbaumer,H.J.1982,Fast Fourier Transform and Convolution Algorithms(New York:Springer- 三 Verlag). Elliott,D.F.,and Rao.K.R.1982.Fast Transforms:Algorithms.Analyses,Applications(New York: Academic Press). Brigham,E.O.1974,The Fast Fourier Transform (Englewood Cliffs,NJ:Prentice-Hall).[1] Bloomfield,P.1976.Fourier Analysis of Time Series-An Introduction(New York:Wiley). Van Loan,C.1992,Computational Frameworks for the Fast Fourier Transform (Philadelphia: S.IA.M.). Beauchamp,K.G.1984,Applications of Walsh Functions and Related Functions (New York: Academic Press)[non-Fourier transforms]. Heideman,M.T.,Johnson,D.H.,and Burris,C.S.1984,IEEE ASSP Magazine,pp.14-21(Oc- 9 tober). Press. 12.3 FFT of Real Functions,Sine and Cosine Transforms 。 SCIENTIFIC It happens frequently that the data whose FFT is desired consist of real-valued samples fi,j=0...N-1.To use four1,we put these into a complex array with all imaginary parts set to zero.The resulting transform Fn,n =0...N-1 satisfies FN*FSince this complex-valued array has real values for Fo and FN/2,and(N/2)-1 other independent values F1...FN/2-1,it has the same 2(N/2-1)+2 N"degrees of freedom"as the original,real data set.However, the use of the full complex FFT algorithm for real data is inefficient.both in execution 兴彩 Numerical Recipes 10.621 43106 time and in storage required.You would think that there is a better way. There are two better ways.The first is "mass production":Pack two separate real functions into the input array in such a way that their individual transforms can (outside be separated from the result.This is implemented in the program twofft below. North This may remind you of a one-cent sale,at which you are coerced to purchase two of an item when you only need one.However,remember that for correlations and convolutions the Fourier transforms of two functions are involved,and this is a handy way to do them both at once.The second method is to pack the real input array cleverly,without extra zeros,into a complex array of half its length.One then performs a complex FFT on this shorter length;the trick is then to get the required answer out of the result.This is done in the program realft below
510 Chapter 12. Fast Fourier Transform Permission is granted for internet users to make one paper copy for their own personal use. Further reproduction, or any copyin Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Cambridge University Press. Programs Copyright (C) 1988-1992 by Numerical Recipes Software. Sample page from NUMERICAL RECIPES IN C: THE ART OF SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING (ISBN 0-521-43108-5) g of machinereadable files (including this one) to any server computer, is strictly prohibited. To order Numerical Recipes books or CDROMs, visit website http://www.nr.com or call 1-800-872-7423 (North America only), or send email to directcustserv@cambridge.org (outside North America). integer arithmetic modulo some large prime N+1, and the Nth root of 1 by the modulo arithmetic equivalent. Strictly speaking, these are not Fourier transforms at all, but the properties are quite similar and computational speed can be far superior. On the other hand, their use is somewhat restricted to quantities like correlations and convolutions since the transform itself is not easily interpretable as a “frequency” spectrum. CITED REFERENCES AND FURTHER READING: Nussbaumer, H.J. 1982, Fast Fourier Transform and Convolution Algorithms (New York: SpringerVerlag). Elliott, D.F., and Rao, K.R. 1982, Fast Transforms: Algorithms, Analyses, Applications (New York: Academic Press). Brigham, E.O. 1974, The Fast Fourier Transform (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall). [1] Bloomfield, P. 1976, Fourier Analysis of Time Series – An Introduction (New York: Wiley). Van Loan, C. 1992, Computational Frameworks for the Fast Fourier Transform (Philadelphia: S.I.A.M.). Beauchamp, K.G. 1984, Applications of Walsh Functions and Related Functions (New York: Academic Press) [non-Fourier transforms]. Heideman, M.T., Johnson, D.H., and Burris, C.S. 1984, IEEE ASSP Magazine, pp. 14–21 (October). 12.3 FFT of Real Functions, Sine and Cosine Transforms It happens frequently that the data whose FFT is desired consist of real-valued samples fj , j = 0 ...N − 1. To use four1, we put these into a complex array with all imaginary parts set to zero. The resulting transform F n, n = 0 ...N − 1 satisfies FN−n* = Fn. Since this complex-valued array has real values for F0 and FN/2, and (N/2) − 1 other independent values F1 ...FN/2−1, it has the same 2(N/2 − 1) + 2 = N “degrees of freedom” as the original, real data set. However, the use of the full complex FFT algorithm for real data is inefficient, both in execution time and in storage required. You would think that there is a better way. There are two better ways. The first is “mass production”: Pack two separate real functions into the input array in such a way that their individual transforms can be separated from the result. This is implemented in the program twofft below. This may remind you of a one-cent sale, at which you are coerced to purchase two of an item when you only need one. However, remember that for correlations and convolutions the Fourier transforms of two functions are involved, and this is a handy way to do them both at once. The second method is to pack the real input array cleverly, without extra zeros, into a complex array of half its length. One then performs a complex FFT on this shorter length; the trick is then to get the required answer out of the result. This is done in the program realft below
