2.Neat Thermoplastic Resins Properties 2.1 Introduction Plastics are commonly classified into two classes.thermoplastics or thermosets, depending on their behavior when heated (4.5.6).A thermoset polymer undergoes various degrees of cross-linking when cured by heat (or other means)[6l.The cross-linking reactions lead to the formation of an insoluble or infusible rigid product,a"set"product,in which chains are joined together to form a three-dimensional structure (5,7].In contrast,thermoplastic polymers do not undergo chemical changes during consolidation:changes are substantially physical [5,6].Generally.thermoplastics are melt fusible and can be consolidated by the application of heat and pressure only.They can be repeatedly sottened by heating and hardened by cooling.There are however some polymers categorized as thermosetting ther- moplastics or pscudo-thermoplastics [1.6,8].They are considercd as thermoplastic as they possess true thermoplastic properties but they are produced essentially like thermosets:they undergo some reaction chemistry during processing cycles.These materials require both curing and heat treatment for effective consolidation (6]. Thermoplastic polymers are not new:they have been known for a long time.It is only recently that the newer so-called high temperature or high performance thermoplastics have been introduced.The early thermoplastic polymers had predominantly aliphatic carbon back- bones in which flexible carbon chains could be extended and rotated into many configurations with relative ease [4,9.10].Rigidity was obtained by restricting the movement of the backbone chain elther by crystallinity such as in polyethylene and polypropylene or by the introduction of side groups as in polystyrene or polymethylmethacrylate.The major limitations with these early thermoplastics which are still on the market are their low elastic modulus,low glass transition temperature (Tg)and poor solvent resistance.In the past few years,a range of thermoplastics based on aromatic polymers have been developed which surmount these limitations.The introduction of rigid aromatic rings instead of aliphatic chains increases the intermolecular forces,thus restricting the movement of the backbone chain [4,10].Hence, mechanical properties,high temperature capability and solvent resistance are greatly improved and can be often equivalent or even better than the best thermosets.For ease of processing.groups such as ether.carbonyl,thioether.amide,methylene,ester.isopropylidine and sulfone are incorporated between the aromatic rings to render the polymer chain more flexible [1,10]. This section presents data on a number of these high performance thermoplastic resins which have the potential to be used as matrix material in fibre reinforced composites aimed at aircraft structural applications.The chemical structure,trade name and producers of these resins as well as their thermal and mechanical properties and solvent resistance are presented. A brief description of each polymer follows which highlights their important characteristics. 3
2. Neat Thermoplastic Resins Properties 2.1 Introduction Plastics are commonly classified into two classes, thermoplastics or thermosets, depending on their behavior when heated 14, 5, S]. A thermoset polymer undergoes various degrees of cross-linking when cured by heat (or other means] IS]. The cross-linking reactions lead to the formation of an insoluble or infusible rigid product, a “set” product, in which chains are joined together to form a three-dimensional structure 15, 71. In contrast, thermoplastic polymers do not undergo chemical changes during consolidation: changes are substantially physical 15, 61. Generally, thermoplastics are melt fusible and can be consolidated by the application of heat and pressure only. They can be repeatedly softened by heating and hardened by cooling. There are however some polymers categorized as thermosetting thermoplastics or pseudo-thermoplastics [ 1, 6. 81. They are considered as thermoplastic as they possess true thermoplastic properties but they are produced essentially like thermosets: they undergo some reaction chemistry during processing cycles. These materials require both curing and heat treatment for effective consolidation 161. Thermoplastic polymers are not new: they have been known for a long time. It is only recently that the newer so-called high temperature or high performance thermoplastics have been introduced. The early thermoplastic polymers had predominantly aliphatic carbon backbones in which flexible carbon chains could be extended and rotated into many configurations with relative ease [4. 9. 101. Rigidity was obtained by restricting the movement of the backbone chain either by crystallinity such as in polyethylene and polypropylene or by the introduction of side groups as in polystyrene or polymethylmethacrylate. The major limitations with these early thermoplastics which are still on the market are their low elastic modulus, low glass transition temperature (Tg) and poor solvent resistance. In the past few years, a range of thermoplastics based on aromatic polymers have been developed which surmount these limitations. The introduction of rigid aromatic rings instead of aliphatic chains increases the intermolecular forces, thus restricting the movement of the backbone chain [4, lo]. Hence, mechanical properties, high temperature capability and solvent resistance are greatly improved and can be often equivalent or even better than the best thermosets. For ease of processing, groups such as ether, carbonyl, thioether. amide, methylene. ester, isopropylidine and sulfone are incorporated between the aromatic rings to render the polymer chain more flexible 11. 101. This section presents data on a number of these high performance thermoplastic resins which have the potential to be used as matrix material in fibre reinforced composites aimed at aircraft structural applications. The chemical structure, trade name and producers of these resins as well as their thermal and mechanical properties and solvent resistance are presented. A brief description of each polymer follows which highlights their important characteristics. 3
4 High Performance Thermoplastic Resins and Their Composites 2.2 Properties of Neat Thermoplastic Resins 2.2.1 Chemical Structure and Some Physical Properties Table 1 lists the high performance thermoplastic polymers that are discussed in the present report.Although this list is not exhaustive,it provides a good indication of the thermoplastics that have been and are being investigated for use as matrix materials for high performance composites.Most of these neat resins are either commercially available or nearly so,in either industrial or developmental quantities.Some of them are provided as a neat resin or filled with short fibres but not yet reinforced with continuous fibres in a prepreg tape or fabric form.Although it is included in the present list,polyphenylquinoxaline (PPQ)is not expected to be avallable in the form of fibre reinforced matrix because of its low modulus,high viscosity and its high cost. Table 2 presents the chemical structure of some of these thermoplastics.The dominant aromattc character in their polymer backhone is clearly shown.Density.Poisson's ratio. Limiting Oxygen Index(L.O.I.)and viscosity are presented in Table 3.Density varles from 1.15 to 1.45 depending on the thermoplastic matrix:the polyamide J-2,a product from E.I.Dupont de Nemours,has the lowest density while N-polymer,a polyimide from Dupont and Eymyd,a polyimide from Ethyl Corporation.have the highest. The melt viscosities of high-molecular weight thermoplastics are much higher than most thermoscts.At processing temperature,thermosets have viscosities less than 1000 poise [2],which is much less than the viscosities presented in Table 3 for thermoplastics.The low viscosity of epoxy formulations results in high melt nlow properties in the uncured state leading to good wetting of the fibres during prepreg manufacture [1l.Figure 1 shows the relationship between solution viscosity.melt viscosity,number average molecular weight and the glass transition temperature (Tg)presented in [9].As shown,the desired high Tg leads inevitably to high melt viscosity.Unfortunately,the high melt viscosity of thermoplastics renders processing difficult as high processing temperatures are required to achieve a low melt viscosity for good consolidation and fibre impregnation:and the viscosity may still be too high for complete impregnation of continuous fibre bundles.Processing becomes difficult at melt viscosities above 5500 poise [9].Melt viscosities of 102 to 104 poise are desirable for the fabrication of composites [1].It is then a question of compromise between processability of thermoplastic composites and their high temperature performance as reflected by Tg. L.O.I.numbers found in Table 3 give an indication of the material's resistance to burning,which may be very important in certain applications.For example,aircraft interiors such as sidewall panels,storage bins.partitions,galley doors and celling panels have to meet certain combustibility requirements to comply to the more and more stringent U.S.Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)cabin safety regulations [57]."L.O.I.is the minimum
4 High Performance Thermoplastic Resins and Their Composites 2.2 Properties of Neat Thermoplastic Resins 2.2.1 Chemical Structure and Some Physical Properties Table 1 lists the high performance thermoplastic polymers that are discussed in the present report. Although this list is not exhaustive, it provides a good Indication of the thermoplastics that have been and are being investigated for use as matrix materials for high performance composites. Most of these neat resins are either commercially available or nearly so, in either industrial or developmental quantities. Some of them are provided as a neat resin or filled with short fibres but not yet reinforced with continuous fibres in a prepreg tape or fabric form. Although it is included in the present list, polyphenylquinoxaline (PPQ) is not expected to be available in the form of fibre reinforced matrix because of its low modulus, high viscosity and its high cost. Table 2 presents the chemical structure of some of these thermoplastics. The dominant aromatic character in their polymer backbone is clearly shown. Density, Poisson’s ratio, Limiting Oxygen Index (L.O.I.) and viscosity are presented in Table 3. Density varies from 1.15 to 1.45 depending on the thermoplastic matrix: the polyamide J-2, a product from E.I. DuPont de Nemours, has the lowest density while N-polymer, a polyimide from DuPont and Eymyd, a polyimide from Ethyl Corporation, have the highest. The melt viscosities of high-molecular weight thermoplaslics are much higher than most thermosets. At processing temperature. thermosets have viscosities less than 1000 poise [2]. which is much less than the viscosities presented in Table 3 for thermoplastics. The low viscosity of epoxy formulations results in high melt flow properties in the uncured state leading to good wetting of the fibres during prepreg manufacture 111. Figure 1 shows the relationship between solution viscosity, melt viscosity, number average molecular weight and the glass transition temperature (Tg) presented in 191. As shown, the desired high Tg leads inevitably to high melt viscosity. Unfortunately, the high melt viscosity of thermoplastics renders processing difficult as high processing temperatures are required to achieve a low melt viscosity for good consolidation and fibre impregnation: and the viscosity may still be too high for complete impregnation of continuous fibre bundles. Processing becomes difficult at melt viscosities above 5500 poise [9]. Melt viscosities of 102 to 104 poise are desirable for the fabrication of composites [ 11. It is then a question of compromise between processability of thermoplastic composites and their high temperature performance as reflected by Tg. L.O.I. numbers found in Table 3 give an indication of the material’s resistance to burning, which may be very important in certain applications. For example, aircraft interiors such as sidewall panels, storage bins, partitions. galley doors and ceiling panels have to meet certain combustibility requirements to comply to the more and more stringent U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) cabin safety regulations [57]. “L.O.I. is the minimum
TABLE 1.Selected High-Performance Thermoplastics GENERIC NAME MANUFACTURER TRADE NAME POLYKETONES Polyetheretherketone (PEEK) Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI) Victrex PEEK Polyetherketone (PEK) Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI) Victrex PEK Polyetherketoneketone (PEKK) E.I.Dupont de Nemours PEKK (1) Polyetherketoneetherketoneketone (PEKEKK) BASF Ultrapek Polyketone Amoco Performance Products Kadel POLYARYLENE SULFIDES Polyphenylene sulfide (PPS) Phillips Petroleum Company Rylon PPS Polyarylene sultide (PAS) Phillips Petroleum Company Ryton PAS-2 (2) Polyphenylene sulfide sulfone (PPSS) Phillips Petroleum Company Ryton S PPSS (2) POLYAMIDES Polyamide E.I.Dupont de Nemours J-2(1.2) Polyamideimide (PAI) Amoco Performance Products Torlon POLYIMIDES Polyaryleneimide E.1.Dupont de Nemours K-Polymer Polyaryleneimide E.I.Dupont de Nemours N-Polymer Polyimide Ethyl Corporation EYMYD Polyetherimide (PEI) General Electric Company Ultem Polyetherimide American Cyanamid Cypac Polyketoimide Mitsui Toatsu Chemicals Inc.(MTC) Larc-TPI,New-TPI Polykeloimide Rogers Corp. Durimid (1)Is or will be available only as custom finished composite material parts (2)Not commercially available but nearly Neat Thermoplastic Resins Properties (3)Not expected to be commcrcially available as a matrix for composite material (continued) n
TABLE 1. Selected High-Performance Thermoplastics GENERIC NAME MANUFACTURER POLYKETONES Polyelherelherketone (PEEK) Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI) Potyelherkelone (PEK) Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI) Polyelherkeloneketone (PEKK) E.I. DuPont de Nemours Polyelherketoneelherkeloneketone (PEKEKK) BASF Polykelone Amoco Performance Products POLYARYLENE SULFIDES Polyphenylene sulfide (PPS) Phillips Petroleum Company Polyarytene sulfide (PAS) Phillips Pelroleum Company Polyphenylene sulfide sulfone (PPSS) Phillips Petroleum Company POLYAMIDES Polyamide E.I. DuPont de Nemours Polyamideimide (PAI) Amoco Performance Products POLYIMIDES Polyaryleneimide E.I. DuPont de Nemours Polyaryleneimide E.I. DuPont de Nemours Polyimide Ethyl Corporation Polyelherimide (PEt) General Electric Company Polyelherimide American Cyanamid Polykeloimide Milsui Toatsu Chemicals Inc. (MTC) Polyketoimide Rogers Corp., TRADE NAME Viclrex PEEK Victrex PEK PEKK (1) Ultrapek Kadet Rylon PPS Ryton PAS-2 (2) Rylon S PPSS (2) J-2 (1,2) Torlon K-Polymer N-Polymer EYMYD Ultem Cypac Larc-TPI, New-TPt Durimid (1) Is or will be available only as custom finished composite material parts (2) Not commercially available but nearly (3) Not expected to be commercially available as a matrix for composite material Ip (continued) ; c. z
TABLE 1.Selected High-Performance Thermoplastics(cont'd) GENERIC NAME MANUFACTURER TRADE NAME POLYSULFONES Polysulfone (PSU) Amoco Performance Products Udel Polyarylethersulfone Amoco Pertormance Products Radel A Polyphenylsulfone Amoco Performance Products Radel R Polyethersulfone (PES) Imperial Chemical Industries Viclrex PES POLYESTERS Liquid Crystalline (LCP) Amoco Performance Products Xydar Liquid Crystalline Hoescht Celancse Vectra POLYBENZIMIDAZOLES High Performance Thermoplastic Resins and Their Composites Polybenzimidazoles (PBI) Hoescht Celanese PBI (1) POLYPHENYLQUINOXALINES Polyphenylquinoxallnes (PPQ)(3) (1)Is or will be available as custom finished composite material parts (2)Not commercially available but nearly so (3)Not expected to be commercially available as a matrix for composite material
TABLE 1. Selected High-Performance Thermoplastics (cont’d) GENERIC NAME POLYSULFONES Polysulfone (PSU) Polyarylethersulfone Polyphenylsulfone Polyethersulfone (PES) POLYESTERS Liquid Crystalline (LCP) Liquid Crystalline POLYBENZIMIDAZOLES Polybenzimidazoles (PBI) POLYPHENYLQUINOXALINES Polyphenylquinoxalines (PPQ) (3) MANUFACTURER TRADE NAME Amoco Performance Products Udel Amoco Performance Products Radel A Amoco Performance Products Radel R Imperial Chemical Industries Victrex PES Amoco Performance Products Xydar Hoescht Celanese Vectra Hoescht Celanese PBI (1) _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ (1) Is or will be available as custom finished composite material parts (2) Not commercially available but nearly so (3) Not expected to be commercially available as a matrix for composite material
Neat Thermoplastic Resins Properties 7 TABLE 2.Chemical Structure of Some High Performance Thermoplastics Polymer Chemical Structure Reference VICTREX PEEK {@-@--@-1 1,2 VICTREX PEK @-O-1 11 PEKK 0-0-801 2,12 RYTON PPS 1,2 小2 [-0,088- 0 TORLON f-oc-a 1,2 0 R- r⊙ R= N-POLYMER (95%) N一 or 1,2 (5%) (continued)
Neat Thermoplastic Resins Properties 7 TABLE 2. Chemical Structure of Some High Performance Thermoplastics Polymer VICTREX PEEK VICTREX PEK PEKK RYTON PPS J-2 TORLON N-POLYMER Chemical Structure Reference iw3” 0 c R 0 : - (RI 3 n II 0 132 11 2,12 192 1 192 192 (continued)
8 High Performance Thermoplastic Resins and Their Composites TABLE 2.Chemical Structure of Some High Performance Thermoplastics(cont'd) Polymer Chemical Structure Reference 8 EYMYD 13 n CH3 UITEM 00 0 1,2 CH3 n LARC-TPI 1,2 UDEL 02000 1,14 CH RADEL A [@-@--@-0:回-1 RADEL R @-@-0-@-0,①-1 14 VICTREX PES [@0@-1 1,14 (continued)
8 High Performance Thermoplastic Resins and Their Composites TABLE 2. Chemical Structure of Some High Performance Thermoplastics (cont’d) EYMYD UITEM LARC-TPI UDEL RADEL A RADEL R VICTREX PES Chemical Structure r 0 0 1 Reference 13 192 192 1,14 1 14 1,14 (continued)
Neat Thermoplastic Resins Properties 9 TABLE 2.Chemical Structure of Some High Performance Thermoplastics(cont'd) Polymer Chemical Structure Reference XYDAR oo.iogfoi VECTRA [oifoo 15,16 CELAZOLE 17,18 PPQ 1,19
Neat Thermoplastic Resins Properties 9 TABLE 2. Chemical Structure of Some High Performance Thermoplastics (cont’d) Polymer Chemical Structure XYDAR VECTRA CELAZOLE PPQ 1 15,16 17,16 1,19
6 TABLE 3.Density,Poisson Ratio,L.O.I.and Viscosity of High-Performance Neat Thermoplastic Resins 香 Resin Density(gcm3)】 Poisson Ratio L01.% Viscosity (poise)' Reference Performance Victrex PEEK 1.30 34000 20 1.27·1.32 0.42 35 21 1.30 35 12 1.30 35000 2 Victrex PEK 1.30 40 22 Thermoplastic PEKK 1.30 40 12 1.30 25000 2 KADFI 1.30 23 Resins Ryton PPS 1.35 44 24 罩 1.36 44 25-30 1.36 25000 20 Their Ryton PAS-2 1.40 46 28-30 1.40 0.41 31 Ryton S PPSS 1.40 0.41 31 J.2 1.15 32 Composites 10000 2 1.15 10000 20 TORLON 1.40 43 33· 1.38 >100000 2 K-POLYMER 1.31 0.365 34,35 1.31 >100000 2 N-POLYMER 1.43·1.45 36.38 1.44 >1000000 2 EYMYD 1.45 13 1.39 39 (continued)
TABLE 3. Density, Poisson Ratio, L.O.I. and Viscosity of High-Performance Neat Thermoplastic Resin: Resin Density (g/cm3 ) Poisson Ratio L.O.I. (%) Viclrex PEEK 1.30 1.27 - 1.32 0.42 35 1.30 35 Viclrex PEK PEKK Viscosity (poise)’ Reference 34000 20 21 12 35000 2 22 12 25000 2 23 24 25 - 30 25000 20 28 - 30 31 31 32 10000 2 10000 20 33 . > 100000 2 34. 35 >100000 2 36 - 36 > 1000000 2 13 39 (continued)
TABLE 3.Density,Poisson Ratio,L.O.I.and Viscosity of High Performance Neat Thermoplastic Resins(cont'd) Resin Density(g/cm)】 Poisson Ratio L.O.L.(%】 Viscosity (poise)* Reference ULTEM 1.27.1.29 47 40 1.27 47 41 1.27 20000 2.14 CYPAC 1.29 41 1.28 42 1.29·1.33 43 LARC-TPI (MTC) 1.40 47 44 >100000 2 DURIMID 1.37 0.36 45,46 UDEL 1.24·1.25 0.37 30 14 1.24 20000 20 RADELA 1.37 33 14 1.37 23 RADEL R 1.29 38 14 1.28 >42 47 VICTREX PES 1.37 0.40 38 14,48,49 XYDAR 1.35 42 50.52 VECTRA 1.40 35·50 53 CELAZOLE 1.30 0.34 58 17 5208*▣ 1.27 54 52450** 1.25 <1000 54 Neat Thermoplastic Viscosity at processing temperature First generation epoxy Bismaleimide (BMI)modified epoxy Resins Properties
TABLE 3. Density, Poisson Ratio, L.O.I. and Viscosity of High Performance Neat Thermoplastic Resins (cont’d) t Viscosity at processing temperature l * First generation epoxy l ** Bismaleimide (BMI) modified epoxy
12 High Performance Thermoplastic Resins and Their Composites 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 20 40 60 Number Average Molecular Weight,in Thousands FIG,1a:Victrex PES Reduced VIscosity vs.Number Average Molecular Weight 0.54 0.50 0.42 0.38 0.34 0.30 0.2 0.4 0.6 Melt Viscosity (400C,1000 s-1),KNsm-2 FIG.1b:Victrex PES Reduced VIscosity vs.Melt VIscoslty 230 226 222 218 214 210 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Reduced Viscosity FIG.1c:Victrex PES Glass Transition Temperature vs. Reduced Viscosity FIGURE 1.Relationship Between Solution Viscosity(RV),Melt Viscosity, Number Average Molecular Weight(Mn)and Glass Transition Temperature (Tg)of Victrex PES [9]
12 High Performance Thermoplastic Resins and Their Composites z 0 20 40 60 Number Average Molecular Weight, in Thousands FIG. la: Victrex PES Reduced Viscosity vs. Number Average Molecular Weight g 0.54 ;- 0.50 % ae 0.46 r ; 0.42 8 4 0.38 > $ 0.34 s p 0.30 I I I 1 K 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 Melt Viscosity (4OO”C, 1000 s-l), KNsm-* FIG. 1 b: Vlctrex PES Reduced Vlscoslty vs. Melt Viscosity 230 - Reduced Viscosity FIG. lc: Victrex PES Glass Transition Temperature vs. Reduced Viscosity FIGURE 1. Relationship Between Solution Viscosity (RV), Melt Viscosity, Number Average Molecular Weight (Mn) and Glass Transition Temperature (Tg) of Victrex PES [9]